I was in the car today when I heard Genesis' song "Hold On My Heart". It reminded me of one of the first times I ever heard the song... I was driving home late at night after being at my boyfriend's house, and the song made me cry.
Two other songs that always used to make me cry (and still do, sometimes)... please don't laugh... Kenny Rogers' "She Believes In Me" and Barry Manilow's "Could It Be Magic".
Two other songs that make me cry for a completely different reason... Beatles' "Revolution #9" and ELO's "Fire On High"... backwards masking always creeps me out.
What songs make you cry?