Comp mentioned "Love Is All That Remains" in the other thread and it got me thinking. We've already got a thread discussing likely/deserving tracks for the next album...the frontrunners if you will. What about some dark horse candidates, songs that didn't make the cut before but...maybe should have?

The question of resurrecting an older "passed-by" track or a demo for inclusion as a bona fide album track is always an interesting one, and there is some precedent for it actually happening ("Walking On The Spot").

So whaddya say folks! If Crowded House were going to raise one bygone Finn song from the dead, dust it off, take a look at it and say "Let's put this one on the album!" - what would be your pick?

"I'm sure whatever he does will be appropriate and fantastic." - Martine

Original Post
"Convent Girls"! (Anytime I get a chance to mention this song, I do). I yelled out to Neil to play it in NYC, but all I got was a wry look of disapproval from a young lady in front. Yes, I knew it was a long shot...and from what someone posted here, not one of Neil's favorites. But who can resist that soaring chorus?? Eh?? Smiler
I don't remember where I have Love is All that Remains. All I can hear in my head from it is that one line!! Where do I have that song stashed away!! I want to remember how it goes!!

Otherwise, Spirit of the Stairs!

Convent Girls would be good too. Maybe what we really need is another Afterglow.
quote:
Originally posted by Shadowman:
Time on earth!


Agreed! Get the final lyrics sorted and put it on the new album. Putting it on the Time on Earth album would have been a little predictable anyway. Wink

I'd like to hear the band give a go at Tail of a Comet. Great song, great lyrics! Smiler

Love is All That Remains and Spirit of the Stairs: to me, these two seem more like "Neil solo" songs which is how I know them. I think I can see LIATR as a CH song, but I really have a hard time imagining SOTS as a Crowded House song. I seem to be only able to think of Neil and his acoustic playing SOTS - even the studio track version that is kicking around doesn't feel quite right to me.

However, if CH wanted to give SOTS a try, I'd be willing give it a listen or three. Big Grin
I think Crowded House considered "Spirit of the Stairs" for the Recurring Dream album or at least for the follow up to Together Alone album. They recorded a demo of it anyway so I think that makes it fair game.

"Love is All that Remains" and "Time On Earth" go hand in hand as Neil solo songs. They were both written around the same time and debuted together during a webcast promoting the One All release. Just because Neil liked the phrase "Time on Earth" and used it as an album title doesn't mean the song is right for Crowded House.
quote:
Originally posted by Paināporo:
"Love is All that Remains" and "Time On Earth" go hand in hand as Neil solo songs. They were both written around the same time and debuted together during a webcast promoting the One All release. Just because Neil liked the phrase "Time on Earth" and used it as an album title doesn't mean the song is right for Crowded House.

It's an interesting question what Neil will do with the songs that come to him now, that don't really "fit" the Crowded House context. Save 'em up for a future solo album? Try to adapt them to fit the CH context?

And then of course the band has stretched, has to an extent branched out, rhythmically and texturally. It will be a challenge to consolidate the musical gains they've made as a performing unit over these past two tours, while still retaining the band's unique identity and focus.

Hm. I feel like I had a point back when I started typing that. Oh well - that'll have to do!
I agree--new album; new songs. Save the leftovers to rack up some cash on the ever forthcoming Crowded House Box with rarities, demos, B - sides, etc.

Also I'd love to see a LIVE box set culled from all of the great live performances they'd done with Paul was still with them. With all of the banter. Ones that get the full production and any sonic buffing up they can do.
quote:
Originally posted by Dm7/G:
I don't think Neil lives in the past so neither should we. I am for all new songs and an all new CD.


I believe the point of this thread was to discuss what old songs might be on the new CH album so that's what we're doing.

Neil may not live in the past but he does spend a lot of time visiting it. Of the last 4 CH shows I've attended, 90% of the material was from the original CH albums and 0% of it was from anything Neil wrote and recorded between 1996-2005. Also, of the 4 original Crowded House albums, both the debut and Together Alone included songs from Neil's Past. "I Walk Away", "Walking on the Spot", and "Catherine Wheels", for example, and those are just the ones we know about. He may have sneaked in a couple other old ones from time to time without telling anyone. My point is that there is clearly a president for this conversation.

I think it's more likely that the band will record a recent rarity than that they'll go back and record some Woodface outtakes but you really never know. After all, "Walking on the Spot" was around for a good 10 years and "Catherine Wheels" for about 15.
Personally I think one or two of his solo stuff should be rerecorded with Crowded House. Such as 'Hole in the Ice'. It would give some of those great songs more exposure.

Also one of the best Finn songs ever, for me anyway, is 'Message To My Girl'. Now thats quite an obscure Split Enz song for most people (Split Enz albums aren't available in the UK). So revisting that now would be interesting and it would do well I think. Its a classic song.
Much as I love Most Unwanted I think it's moment has passed. (I always thought the lyric was "In my dreams I've wrestled with gods". Much better than Neil's lyric, in my humble opinion!).

Anyway, back on topic: I think the only true contender is Spirit Of The Stairs.
quote:

originally postes by painaporo
I believe the point of this thread was to discuss what old songs might be on the new CH album so that's what we're doing.



Oh, by all means, go right ahead with your useless pusuits.

None of the "old" songs are going to make it on their next CD. This is a band moving forward, not lost in the past. Every band has to play their "oldies" in concert. That's what the fans expect. Retreading old tires is best left for the rarities set.
quote:
Originally posted by Dm7/G:
quote:

originally postes by painaporo
I believe the point of this thread was to discuss what old songs might be on the new CH album so that's what we're doing.



Oh, by all means, go right ahead with your useless pusuits.

None of the "old" songs are going to make it on their next CD. This is a band moving forward, not lost in the past. Every band has to play their "oldies" in concert. That's what the fans expect. Retreading old tires is best left for the rarities set.


I dont think that was very nice we are not saying they will be its just a lyrical kick about between Frenz on what stuff really they think should have made an album no one is saying we want oldies thats it! of COURSE we want to hear new stuff but old stuff is CLASSICS and always will be!
Neil and Ch are so talented and creative and we love them for this and this is songs that never made it onto album that if there were to be one which tracks unreleased would you have on an "album"
that is my gist of it, Nothing serious nor meant to be that way imho
quote:
I dont think that was very nice we are not saying they will be its just a lyrical kick about between Frenz on what stuff really they think should have made an album no one is saying we want oldies thats it! of COURSE we want to hear new stuff but old stuff is CLASSICS and always will be!



Oh please, stop taking this all so seriously. I meant no harm in my remarks. If you took offense that's would be copping an attitude.

I think I'll start a thread, "The likelihood of Neil playing at my BBQ party in July."
quote:
Originally posted by Dm7/G:
I think I'll start a thread, "The likelihood of Neil playing at my BBQ party in July."


You could of course start any thread you like but I think that one should go into the Neil Finn solo section of the forum. Though, unlike the current discussion, there is no precedent for anyone to believe that Neil might actually play your BBQ.

Also, when people are having a conversation about anything at all, no matter how "useless" you may think it is, it's still rude to come in and try to stomp it out with a ridiculous statement like "Neil doesn't live in the past and neither should we! Viva la actuel!"

There are plenty of threads in this forum that are little more than community daydreaming so I suggest you either try to say something a bit more constructive or save your energy for topics you actually care about.
Thank you Deb.

Then I will second the emotion and vote once more for 'Spirit of the Stairs'.

Neil mentioned to a group of us after the LA concert on Sat. night that he was just weeks from putting finishing touches on a 'rarities' album. He is well aware of his fans fondness for his 'obscure' (please don't cane me for using that word!!) works!! So... if it shows up there, bully! If it shows up on a new release, bully bully! Otherwise I will continue to watch a brief snippet on youtube and long for the day...
quote:
Originally posted by Paināporo:
both the debut and Together Alone included songs from Neil's Past. "I Walk Away", "Walking on the Spot", and "Catherine Wheels", for example, and those are just the ones we know about. He may have sneaked in a couple other old ones from time to time without telling anyone.


For sure. I've argued a couple times earlier that "Everything Is Good For You" is adapted from "Anyone Can Tell," which was then unreleased.

-Comp
quote:
For sure. I've argued a couple times earlier that "Everything Is Good For You" is adapted from "Anyone Can Tell," which was then unreleased.

Anyone Can Tell was released in 1991 or 92 as a Woodface B-Side, but I agree, the main riffs to both songs are very very similar.

He's known for rewriting songs, Nails In My Feet is basically a rewrite of Fall At Your Feet for example.

quote:
Also "The Same Language As Me"
That did get released, he called it Private Universe in the end.

My votes go to Love Is All That Remains, Tail of a Comet, Convent Girls and Spirit of the Stairs.
quote:
Originally posted by Camus:
quote:
For sure. I've argued a couple times earlier that "Everything Is Good For You" is adapted from "Anyone Can Tell," which was then unreleased.

Anyone Can Tell was released in 1991 or 92 as a Woodface B-Side, but I agree, the main riffs to both songs are very very similar.

Nails In My Feet is basically a rewrite of Fall At Your Feet.


I've always felt that Neil lifted the guitar line from "Anyone Can Tell" for "Everything is Good For You". That fact that they're probably two of my least favorite songs has always linked them in my mind anyway.

As for "Fall At Your Feet" and "Nails in My Feet" I think their similarities are far more subconscious. Like they both mention "feet", sure, but as for the chords, there are only so many progressions out there (esp when you narrow your view to just popular radio songs) so I think Neil just happened to choose a similar progression for NIMF. Same reason "Catherine Wheels" is so much like "Into Temptation" or "Four Seasons in One Day". I believe there's a concert clip where Neil actually sings a medley of all three to show how similar they are.
Yeah, there are only so many chord progressions, but those two are extremely similar, I'd lean more to a rewrite than coincidence, but I guess the Finn is the only one who knows for sure.

It's either the club CD Mood Swinging Men or Eyes of the World where Neil says he rewrote Four Seasons as Catherine Wheels. Remember it's only the chorus that was demoed during the Frenzy rehearsals in 1978, just before someone points out that Catherine Wheels predates Four Seasons Big Grin
quote:
Originally posted by DaFINNative girl:
Thank you Deb.

Then I will second the emotion and vote once more for 'Spirit of the Stairs'.

Neil mentioned to a group of us after the LA concert on Sat. night that he was just weeks from putting finishing touches on a 'rarities' album. He is well aware of his fans fondness for his 'obscure' (please don't cane me for using that word!!) works!! So... if it shows up there, bully! If it shows up on a new release, bully bully! Otherwise I will continue to watch a brief snippet on youtube and long for the day...


Isnt Neil just AMAZING Big Grin that will be one hell of a cool album Smiler and WOW!
quote:
Originally posted by DaFINNative girl:
Neil mentioned to a group of us after the LA concert on Sat. night that he was just weeks from putting finishing touches on a 'rarities' album. He is well aware of his fans fondness for his 'obscure' (please don't cane me for using that word!!) works!!


a NEW rarities album? If he's talking about the rarities box set that makes sense but it kind of sounds like he's talking about an Afterglow II sort of effort. I'd be thrilled with anything of course but I'd hate to think that the box set idea has been abandoned for a single disc release. At any rate, lets hope that "finishing touches" means it (whatever it is) will be released before 2009. Before Fall 2008 would be even better!
quote:
Originally posted by AndiB:
If any kind of rarities compilation comes out I'd love to see "Ray of Hope" on it. It is such a gorgeous song and to have it in a good quality version would be very cool.
Yes your so right that is a really pretty song and A GOOD CLEAR version would be brilliant Smiler
Unfortunately, as you guys have probably already concluded, "Ray of Hope" is unlikely to appear on a Crowded House box set. It was, after all, recorded by Neil in the middle of his solo career. It's ashame though that such a beautiful song should only be released as a very low quality MP3.
quote:
Originally posted by AndiB:
quote:
It's ashame though that such a beautiful song should only be released as a very low quality MP3.


Isn't it available on a CD somewhere though?


If it is, somebody's not sharing or at least nobody here seems to know about it.
quote:

quote:
Also "The Same Language As Me"
That did get released, he called it Private Universe in the end.

Yes it did but I think it's different enough from Private Universe to warrant it's own release with the exception of "it's a pleasure that I have known" part that we all know well from Private Universe.
I agree 100% with Finner79
"Most Unwanted", "Same Language As Me" and "Convent Girls"

All of those songs are highlights of their "Club" albums

Neil would still need to write the Bridge for Most Unwanted as CH never completed it whilst they were writing it on MTV.

I also think "Pieces of Change" has potential.
quote:
Originally posted by Mmxguy07:

Neil would still need to write the Bridge for Most Unwanted as CH never completed it whilst they were writing it on MTV.



Most Unwanted gets my vote. And yeah, Neil has to finish the bridge (it's about time). The lyrics have to include something about someone 'wanting to get up and just, just dance'. THAT would be fitting ;-)
Paul H posted:
Much as I love Most Unwanted I think it's moment has passed. (I always thought the lyric was "In my dreams I've wrestled with gods". Much better than Neil's lyric, in my humble opinion!).

Anyway, back on topic: I think the only true contender is Spirit Of The Stairs.

Been listening to Most Unwanted a lot lately, and have struggled deciding whether he's wrestling with dogs or gods. Is there a definitive answer?

Steve Shealy posted:
Paul H posted:
Much as I love Most Unwanted I think it's moment has passed. (I always thought the lyric was "In my dreams I've wrestled with gods". Much better than Neil's lyric, in my humble opinion!).

Anyway, back on topic: I think the only true contender is Spirit Of The Stairs.

Been listening to Most Unwanted a lot lately, and have struggled deciding whether he's wrestling with dogs or gods. Is there a definitive answer?

I've always thought he sings "wrestled with gods" in one chorus and "wrestled with dogs" in the other. 

Add Reply

Likes (0)
Post
    All times London, UK.

    ©1998-Eternity, Frenz.com. All post content is the copyrighted work of the person who wrote it. Please don't copy, reproduce, or publish anything you see written here without the author's permission.
×
×
×
×
×