Phil Judd and Roger Waters, well, maybe. (To me)
I cannot possibly comment on the John Lennon - Liam Gallagher, as I don't wish to use the c word. One is an incredibly talented singer song writer, and the other one is an angry mop, with a burberry coat on.
Unfortunately for me, Oasis came at a time when I thought "If just one more person tells me how great Manchester is, I shall have to blow them up".