No, you are not the only one. I had no idea it was available via Tim's myspace until people started talking about it here, which was 2 weeks after Peter's email arrived. His email did imply that it was a rare club thing that one had to act quickly on because of extremely limited copies. I didn't enquire about the cost via the fan club, but I assumed it would be about $25US, which is what they always cost. I didn't want it enough to pay that much for it.
The price on the myspace site, however, was worth it to me, and I received it just a few days after I placed my order.
This isn't the first time something like this has happened. I ordered a signed copy of Everyone Is Here from the fan club, well before its release. I waited months and months (and months!) for it. In the intervening time, I went to a Finn Bros show and they were selling signed copies of it for half the price the fan club was charging. And I could have had it in my hands that day. I was not pleased. In fact, that experience made me swear off buying copies of CD's from the fan club, when it is clear those CD's will have a general release.