I quite liked this review. It made want to listen to the Finn album again. I like that Sweetman knows what he likes and knows what he doesn't like. To me, that's no big deal. Nobody said you had to like the entire Finn catalog to be a fan. And come, it is academic that Neil is the better tunesmith. Tim himself would probably even admit to that! And I don't think it's because Neil is just naturally more gifted than Tim. I think Neil legitimately works his *** off when it comes to writing songs, whereas Tim is more likely to stick some pretty words to a pretty melody and call it a day. That's seldom good enough for Neil who has to labor over a song for months or even years before he's finally happy with it.