This is a ridiculously difficult question!
I'll give it a stab, but all of these could very well (and probably will) change by tomorrow (except for Nails In My Feet, which is perfect and therefore never changes ).
Crowded House - Now We're Getting Somewhere
Temple of Low Men - Into Temptation
Woodface - Four Seasons In One Day
Together Alone - Nails In My Feet
Afterglow - Recurring Dream
edit: As I was typing this out, Guy posted his list - imagine my surprise to hit "add reply" and see that our lists were identical except for one song! *laughs* You have good taste, Guy.